‘Let’s Answer This’, a campaign to get key questions on Labour’s proposed water tax answered is gathering momentum – while the fundamentals remain unclear.
The questions were sent to Labour Party leader Jacinda Ardern on Friday 11th August by non profit membership organisation Irrigation New Zealand asking for a confirmed response in writing.
The organisation was prompted to act after a one page statement issued by Jacinda Ardern announcing the water tax provided very little detail on what the tax would involve. Key questions that have not been addressed include the impact of the tax on ordinary New Zealanders, what it will cost, who it will apply to and how it might be implemented.
Irrigation New Zealand has also taken their questions to social media where it is generating lively debate, with two Facebook posts pressing for answers seeing over 12,500 people interacting with the posts.
Comments include questions on why the proposed tax won’t be applied to businesses using town water, given the latest Ministry of the Environment report says urban rivers are generally more polluted than rural ones. Another is why have hydro power generators been let off the hook, given they are commercial users of water that make healthy profits, much of which ends up offshore.
Water tax rate remains uncertain
Since Jacinda Ardern’s announcement on Wednesday 9th August, Labour’s Environment spokesperson David Parker has reportedly quoted significantly different figures for what the tax would cost, from ‘less than $500m’, to $100m*. Confusingly, Parker quoted the lower figure of $100m based on a higher tax rate of 2 cents per thousand litres, as opposed to the one cent per thousand litres he calculated the ‘less than half a billion’ figure on.
Irrigation New Zealand publishes irrigation water tax calculator
To assist Labour and others interested in the water tax debate, Irrigation New Zealand has published a calculator based on water use to better understand the impact of the tax on irrigators, sectors and regions. Users can plug in a cents per 1,000 litres cost and a volume to see the impact of the tax. The calculator can be downloaded as an excel spreadsheet – click the link on the second sentence on this page http://irrigationnz.co.nz/news/advocacy/watertax/
Another unanswered question, however, is if the rate will be calculated on a water use or the maximum water allocated to users through a consent. Water allocations are not always fully used due to NZ’s variable climate – wet and dry years.
Irrigation New Zealand CEO Andrew Curtis said: ‘It’s clear from the wildly different figures quoted by Labour since their initial announcement – from $500 million, to $100 million– that Labour does not understand the impact of this tax and they have scant grasp of the detail on how it will be applied.
‘New Zealanders deserve answers on the water tax. We are asking the questions, but so far Labour is not answering. We’re asking not only on behalf of our members, who contribute $5.5 billion to New Zealand’s economy annually, but on behalf of every New Zealander who will be impacted by this tax.
‘Ultimately the water tax will increase the cost of production, with a knock on effect for New Zealanders and on the country’s international competitiveness. Farmers who are already spending billions upgrading irrigation infrastructure, complying with environmental legislation and upgrading the health of their rivers and lakes will have less to spend. Given the complexities of applying a water tax the money raised will inevitably be chewed up on administering it. A blanket water tax is not the answer.’
*On 10 August in a Radio New Zealand interview Labour’s Environment spokesperson David Parker said the tax at 1 cent per 1000 litres would bring in ‘less than half a billion’. http://www.radionz.co.nz/national/programmes/morningreport/audio/201854206/labour-s-irrigation-charge-about-1c-per-1000l-david-parker
On 13 August on TVNZ’s Q and A programme Labour’s environment spokesperson David Parker said the cost at 2 cents per 1000 litres ‘would be about 100 million dollars across the country for a year’
Labour leader Jacinda Ardern should not answer questions about the party’s proposed water tax by saying it’s about targeting water bottlers, says IrrigationNZ. When Labour Leader Jacinda Ardern was asked in last night’s TVNZ Leader’s Debate whether rural New Zealand….. Read more
Recent attempts to estimate the cost of Labour’s proposed water tax to farmers have demonstrated a basic lack of understanding of how irrigation works, says nonprofit membership body IrrigationNZ. This issue, which is compounded by a lack of detail from….. Read more
Confused members of nonprofit body Irrigation New Zealand are contacting IrrigationNZ asking if a water tax IS going ahead, following Labour’s announcement on tax plans today. While Labour’s tax statement is being called ‘no new taxes this term’ , the water….. Read more
More than 400 farmers and other rural business owners turned out in Ashburton this week to hear National’s policies on the primary sector and the environment and discuss concerns on a raft of new proposed taxes by Greens and Labour,….. Read more
A new survey of irrigators has revealed the potential impact of implementing Labour’s proposal on a water tax, including the news that it is set to lead to more intensive farming. Key findings from the survey conducted by IrrigationNZ were:….. Read more
September 26 @ 10:00 am - 4:30 pm
Proudly supported by our Training Partners TRAINING FOR IRRIGATION OPERATORS AND MANAGERS – IMPROVE YOUR IRRIGATION SKILLS AND KNOWLEDGE CROMWELL Where: Otago Polytech, Bannockburn Rd, Cromwell – Rm 12 When: 10am- 4pm Tuesday 26th September 2017 Cost: IrrigationNZ Members $350 +GST….. Read more
September 28 @ 10:00 am - 4:30 pm
Proudly supported by our Training Partners TRAINING FOR IRRIGATION OPERATORS AND MANAGERS – IMPROVE YOUR IRRIGATION SKILLS AND KNOWLEDGE RANFURLY Where: Wedderburn Cottages – Red Barn, 7145 Wedderburn- Becks Road, Ranfurly When: 10am- 4pM Thursday 28th September 2017 Cost: IrrigationNZ….. Read more
Was only charging irrigators to clean up rivers a mistake? Water quality remains issue under new National Government t.co/8qmsHuNvuh
Gee, there's some amazing farmers with wonderful stories all the way throughout rural NZ t.co/cGf6YZeejP